Residence photography unavailable
01 / 12
For Sale

186 Pigeon Hill Rd

Plymouth, NY 13844

$230K
2 BD · 1 BA · 1,482 sf · 8.08 ac · Built 1885
The residence

Private Retreat with Garage/Workshop & Scenic Views, Chenango County! Discover the charm and tranquility of country living at this distinctive 2-bedroom, 1-bath home situated on 8.08 acres in the Town of Plymouth. Built in 1885, this character-filled property offers a unique blend of rustic appeal, comfortable living space, expansive grounds, and excellent outbuilding potential. The home offers approximately 1,482 square feet of living area, with a 1.5-story layout and partial basement. The interior features a warm, inviting atmosphere with abundant woodwork, distinctive architectural details, large windows, and a comfortable living room. The home offers two bedrooms with room for a third, one full bath, a functional kitchen, and flexible living space throughout. A covered porch provides a relaxing place to enjoy the surrounding countryside. One of the property's standout features is the beautiful private pond, surrounded by mature trees, manicured lawn, and wooded acreage. The pond creates a peaceful focal point and provides an exceptional setting for relaxing, enjoying nature, or creating your own private outdoor retreat. A rustic cabin/outbuilding tucked into the woods adds even more character and potential. For the hobbyist, collector, mechanic, or someone needing substantial workspace, the property includes a 26' x 40' detached garage/workshop built in 1976. The spacious building offers room for vehicles, equipment, projects, storage, and recreational toys. Additional outbuildings provide even more storage and utility space. The acreage offers a wonderful combination of open lawn, mature woods, rolling terrain, and scenic countryside views. The expansive grounds provide plenty of room for gardening, recreation, outdoor entertaining, hobbies, or simply enjoying the privacy and beauty of the property. ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITY: The contents of the home and garage/workshop are available and may be included in the sale or negotiated separately, providing an excellent opportunity for a buyer who appreciates the property's existing furnishings, tools, equipment, collectibles, and other contents. Specific items and terms are subject to negotiation between the buyer and seller. Located in a peaceful rural setting yet within reach of nearby communities and amenities, this property offers a rare opportunity to own a substantial piece of country real estate with a home, pond, woods, garage/workshop, and multiple outbuildings.

At a glance
Property type
Farm
Status
Active
Year built
1885
Lot size
8.08 acres
Living area
1,482 sf
MLS#
11962236
Beds · Baths
2 · 1
Location

Plymouth, NY.

Plymouth, New York, is a market our advisors follow closely — its streets, housing stock and setting each shape what a residence here is worth and how it lives day to day. We are glad to walk you through the locale in detail, and how this particular address sits within it.

Estimated Monthly Payment+
$1K/mo
Approximate · principal & interest only
Display Currency
$230K

Indicative conversion — settlement always in USD.

Private Showing

Arrange a viewing.

A senior advisor will reply personally to coordinate access at a time that suits you. All inquiries are held in confidence.

Submitted in confidence to the listing advisor. By submitting, you consent to be contacted by SZ INC. Realty at the number and email provided, including by call and text; message and data rates may apply, and consent is not a condition of any purchase or lease. See our Privacy Policy.

Listing courtesy of NY OUTDOOR REALTY LLC · NYSMLS

My State MLS / New York State MLS.Listing data is provided by My State MLS / New York State MLS for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate and should be independently verified.

Listings updated Sep 4, 2026

Fair Housing