Shelter Island, NY 11964
SHELTER ISLAND TOWN CENTER INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY: This rare mixed use building with eight rental spaes is centrally located in Shelter Island's "B" Business zone district. Office/retail and residential mix. Plenty of onsite parking. High traffic! Great Cap rate! Are you looking for a 1031? Are you looking for a great investment. Exclusive: $2.75M.
Shelter Island, New York, is a market our advisors follow closely — its streets, housing stock and setting each shape what a residence here is worth and how it lives day to day. We are glad to walk you through the locale in detail, and how this particular address sits within it.
Indicative conversion — settlement always in USD.
A senior advisor will reply personally to coordinate access at a time that suits you. All inquiries are held in confidence.
My State MLS / New York State MLS.Listing data is provided by My State MLS / New York State MLS for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate and should be independently verified.
Listings updated Jul 16, 2026
'%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(0.0000,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M272%20-12C411%20-12%20495%2071%20495%20175C495%20272%20438%20317%20360%20350L267%20390C215%20412%20158%20436%20158%20499C158%20558%20207%20595%20280%20595C338%20595%20388%20571%20429%20535L474%20589C428%20635%20360%20668%20280%20668C160%20668%2074%20594%2074%20494C74%20399%20144%20352%20207%20325L301%20284C363%20256%20410%20235%20410%20168C410%20104%20359%2061%20273%2061C203%2061%20136%2091%2089%20140L42%2086C99%2025%20178%20-12%20272%20-12Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(36.3334,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M45%200H497V71H148L494%20607V656H76V586H390L45%2050Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(86.6149,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M90%200H173V656H90Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(104.5094,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M90%200H169V343C169%20413%20164%20483%20158%20549H162C183%20501%20208%20452%20233%20408L466%200H557V656H477V315C477%20247%20483%20175%20488%20107H484C462%20155%20439%20204%20414%20248L181%20656H90Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(148.5313,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M339%20-12C424%20-12%20485%2022%20538%2082L495%20130C453%2085%20406%2061%20345%2061C218%2061%20138%20165%20138%20330C138%20493%20221%20595%20344%20595C398%20595%20443%20573%20478%20536L523%20587C485%20632%20421%20668%20343%20668C176%20668%2052%20539%2052%20328C52%20114%20175%20-12%20339%20-12Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(187.3822,0)%20scale(0.063000,-0.063000)'%20d='M125%20-12C157%20-12%20184%2014%20184%2050C184%2088%20157%20114%20125%20114C92%20114%2065%2088%2065%2050C65%2014%2092%20-12%20125%20-12Z'/%3e%3c/g%3e%3cg%20fill='%23f4f7fa'%20transform='translate(155.5112%20294.0822)'%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(0.0000,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M90%200H173V277H292L450%200H544L377%20286C467%20308%20525%20370%20525%20472C525%20608%20429%20656%20295%20656H90ZM173%20345V589H283C385%20589%20442%20558%20442%20472C442%20387%20385%20345%20283%20345Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(20.8965,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M90%200H478V71H173V309H422V380H173V586H468V656H90Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(40.7081,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M203%20367C227%20440%20248%20512%20268%20588H272C293%20512%20314%20440%20338%20367L369%20267H172ZM3%200H88L151%20200H390L452%200H541L319%20656H225Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(60.9588,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M90%200H460V71H173V656H90Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(79.7114,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M226%200H310V586H508V656H28V586H226Z'/%3e%3cpath%20transform='translate(99.7555,0)%20scale(0.025830,-0.025830)'%20d='M196%200H280V254L477%20656H390L306%20471C286%20423%20263%20377%20240%20328H236C214%20377%20194%20423%20173%20471L88%20656H-1L196%20254Z'/%3e%3c/g%3e%3c/svg%3e){kind=small}
