Residence photography unavailable
01 / 12
Active Under Contract

21 S FULTON ST #5

Montauk, NY 11954

$1.15M
2 BD · 3 BA · 1,400 sf · 31.34 ac · Built 1982
The residence

Tucked into the sought-after Stepping Stones community, this two-level townhouse delivers an easy, breezy Montauk lifestyle just moments from the ocean. The home spans roughly 1,400 square feet and offers 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a half bath. Downstairs, find two comfortable bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a private deck, and an outdoor storage area for all your beach gear. Climb to the second level, and the home really shines. Three full-sized sliding glass doors, a skylight, and an oversized window above the staircase pour natural light into the open living, dining, and kitchen space, with extra windows in the kitchen adding even more brightness. Step outside onto the upper deck and take in sweeping views of Lake Montauk. A half bath rounds out this level. Set on 30 acres of beautifully maintained, park-like grounds, residents have access to a heated saltwater pool and poolside cabana right on site. Public clay courts at Gotham Tennis, Montauk Harbor and its shops, and the legendary surf at Ditch Plains are all just minutes away. The building recently completed a round of exterior upgrades, including new siding, roof, front door, railings, and electrical work. Monthly maintenance runs $850. Quiet, bright, and full of charm, this is a rare chance to own in one of Montauk's most beloved waterside communities.

At a glance
Property type
Status
Active Under Contract
Year built
1982
Lot size
31.34 acres
Living area
1,400 sf
MLS#
11859527
Beds · Baths
2 · 3
Location

Montauk, NY.

Montauk sits within The Hamptons, in New York, and keeps the character of that stretch of the map — its streets, shoreline and architecture read as of a piece with the towns around it. Our advisors know the market here street by street and can speak to how a particular address sits within it.

Estimated Monthly Payment+
$6K/mo
Approximate · principal & interest only
Display Currency
$1.15M

Indicative conversion — settlement always in USD.

Private Showing

Arrange a viewing.

A senior advisor will reply personally to coordinate access at a time that suits you. All inquiries are held in confidence.

Submitted in confidence to the listing advisor. By submitting, you consent to be contacted by SZ INC. Realty at the number and email provided, including by call and text; message and data rates may apply, and consent is not a condition of any purchase or lease. See our Privacy Policy.

Listing courtesy of The Agency Hamptons · NYSMLS

My State MLS / New York State MLS.Listing data is provided by My State MLS / New York State MLS for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate and should be independently verified.

Listings updated Oct 20, 2026

Fair Housing