Dripping with character dating to circa 1780 and renovated in 2021, the Lieutenant Colonel John Hulbert house is a Sag Harbor Village gem on Captain's Row set on a generous and beautifully landscaped 0.65 acres with a legal guest cottage, heated, gunite, salt water pool and spa with bluestone surround, and an outdoor fireplace. Stunning architectural details abound with the sweeping veranda, exposed beams, and striking walls of glass that imbue modern style with historic charm. Through the entry foyer, the airy great room with soaring ceilings has an open kitchen, living room, and dining room with a wall of glass and French doors to the pool area. An intimate living room with fireplace, den with exposed beams, and guest bedroom suite complete the main level. The well proportioned house has five bedrooms spanning three above grade levels including the two beautifully appointed primary and junior primary suites. The legal guest house with fireplace, adorned with a charming cupola, adds an additional bedroom, full bath, finished lower level with gym, and outdoor shower. Rare opportunity to own an exceedingly stylish and turnkey village gem listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
241 Main Street
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Property type
- Status
- Active
- Year built
- 1780
- Lot size
- 0.64 acres
- Living area
- 5,000 sf
- MLS#
- 12019471
- Beds · Baths
- 6 · 6
Sag Harbor, NY.
Sag Harbor sits within The Hamptons, in New York, and keeps the character of that stretch of the map — its streets, shoreline and architecture read as of a piece with the towns around it. Our advisors know the market here street by street and can speak to how a particular address sits within it.
Estimated Monthly Payment+
Indicative conversion — settlement always in USD.
Arrange a viewing.
A senior advisor will reply personally to coordinate access at a time that suits you. All inquiries are held in confidence.
My State MLS / New York State MLS.Listing data is provided by My State MLS / New York State MLS for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate and should be independently verified.
Listings updated Oct 20, 2026



