Set in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, just one block from Main Street, this Greek Revival-style townhouse at Watchcase offers the privacy and scale of a single-family residence with access to an exceptional suite of luxury amenities. Spanning approximately 3,509 square feet of interior space across four levels, with an additional 724 square feet of exterior space, the residence features four bedrooms, four bathrooms, a private elevator, one-car garage, and a spacious wraparound terrace with an outdoor shower. A welcoming entry porch opens to a gracious foyer and an expansive open-concept living and dining area with a fireplace. French doors lead to the terrace, creating a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living. Also on this level is a versatile den that can serve as a home office or guest bedroom, along with a full bathroom. The second floor is anchored by a generous primary suite featuring walk-in California Closets and an en-suite bathroom with both a soaking tub and separate shower. Two additional guest bedrooms share a full bath, while a comfortable sitting room with its own fireplace provides another inviting space to relax. The finished lower level offers exceptional flexibility, with a mudroom, an additional bedroom or recreation space, a full bathroom, a wet bar, laundry, generous storage, and convenient access to the Watchcase Pool Pavilion and its extensive amenities. On the garage level, the residence includes a private one-car garage within Watchcase's secure, keyed-entry parking facility. Inspired by Sag Harbor's turn-of-the-century sea captains' homes, beachside bungalows, and village cottages, the Watchcase townhouses combine historic character with modern luxury. This residence offers the best of both worlds: the space, privacy, and comfort of a private home together with the convenience and services of one of Sag Harbor's most distinctive residential communities. Watchcase is ideally located just one block from the shops, restaurants, and charm of Main Street and only two blocks from Sag Harbor's deep-water harbor. The community comprises 63 residences, including factory lofts and penthouses, townhouses, and bungalow condominiums. Owners enjoy an extensive amenity package that includes concierge service, superintendent and porter services, the Watchcase Pavilion with saltwater pool, fitness center, yoga studio, locker rooms with sauna, spa treatment room, and an events lounge with fireplace and catering kitchen. The grand lobby living room features the Vault Bar and a dramatic two-sided fireplace. Watchcase Residences have also demonstrated strong rental appeal, with an exclusive rental program designed to make ownership and leasing seamless. Its distinctive architecture, comprehensive amenities, prime Sag Harbor Village location, and effortless lifestyle continue to appeal to both year-round and seasonal tenants. Monthly common charges: $4,972.45 Annual real estate taxes: $5,458.99
25 CHURCH ST Watchcase
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- Property type
- Status
- Active
- Year built
- 2017
- Living area
- 3,509 sf
- MLS#
- 11933227
- Beds · Baths
- 4 · 4
Sag Harbor, NY.
Sag Harbor sits within The Hamptons, in New York, and keeps the character of that stretch of the map — its streets, shoreline and architecture read as of a piece with the towns around it. Our advisors know the market here street by street and can speak to how a particular address sits within it.
Estimated Monthly Payment+
Indicative conversion — settlement always in USD.
Arrange a viewing.
A senior advisor will reply personally to coordinate access at a time that suits you. All inquiries are held in confidence.
My State MLS / New York State MLS.Listing data is provided by My State MLS / New York State MLS for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate and should be independently verified.
Listings updated Oct 20, 2026



